An article in the Meridian Star talks about the human cost in the Social Security Disability system. The reporter talked to a law professor about the human aspect of the legal claims:
There’s a human cost of so much time processing cases and waiting to be approved, says Doron Dorfmann, associate professor at Syracuse University College of Law. He studied the effect of the disability determination process on the claimants, how it affected their perception of themselves as disabled citizens. In a paper cited by Judge Reeves, Dorfmann noted that disability is a fluid concept rather than the rigid definition adopted by the Social Security Administration.
“There’s not a lot of people who look at the procedure from the point of view of the person going through it,” Dorfmann told the Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting.
Dorfmann told the Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting that he has studied what he calls the “fear of the disability con” which is the idea that “the way disability law generally is implemented in the U.S. is that everybody is faking disability. I show in my research that this fear is a driving force in disability law.”
Dorfmann’s studies showed that disability is often a pride issue, with people not wanting to portray themselves as disabled when that is precisely what the Social Security disability process is asking them to do. Such a display plays into how people feel about themselves and their vision of what disability means, Dorfmann noted.
“Do we as a country ask that not all people can ‘overcome’ their impairment?” Dorfmann said.
The article also follows the story of a claimant in Mississippi, Mr. Boatner, through his decade long appeal process, that led to the decision written by United State sDistrict Judge Carlton Reeves, which heavily criticizes the system that failed Mr. Boatner:
In his blistering opinion, he (Judge Reeves) detailed where each component of the disability process had failed Boatner before he then awarded the veteran truck driver his long-denied benefits. Reeves turned his focus on the state agency acting on the Social, Security Administration’s behalf — Disability Determination Services. DDS, which is under the Mississippi Department of Rehabilitation Services, processes cases of people filing for disability benefits from the Social Security Administration.
In his ruling, Reeves described the “waiting” Boatner had to do, saying, “Boatner has spent nearly a decade seeking disability payments from the Social Security Administration, filing his last application in 2014. Despite acknowledging the severity of Boatner’s medical conditions and his trips to death’s doorstep, the Administration has denied each of his four applications. These denials have been painful. One caused Boatner to walk out of his house, put a gun to his head, and threaten to kill himself.”
Boatner told the Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting that throughout his two-decade career as a truck driver, he had always made sure his Social Security taxes were paid up, saying that as he understood it, you paid in and Social Security took care of you if you got old.
When his claims were denied over and over, Boatner said, “I felt plumb stupid.”
In his ruling, Reeves took aim at the disability examiners and the administrative law judge that handled Boatner’s case, noting the ALJ had resolved more than 600 cases in 2016. Reeves also said examiners are not prepared to handle as many cases as SSA asks them to handle.
Mississippi DDS’ 111 examiners processed approximately 64,000 cases last fiscal year, according to Patti Patterson, regional communications director for the Atlanta regional office of the Social Security Administration. Caseloads per examiner range from 65-125 cases, said Chris Howard, head of the Department of Rehabilitation Services.
If you or a family member has been denied Social Security benefits in Mississippi or Louisiana, my firm can help. With offices in Baton Rouge and Shreveport, we cover hearings in Mississippi, including at the hearing offices in Hattiesburg, McComb, Jackson, and Greenville; we cover the entire state of Louisiana, from New Orleans and Marrero, to Lafayette and Lake Charles, to Alexandria and Monroe; and we cover the hearing offices in East Texas, including Houston, Dallas and Tyler. Call me at 225-281-7715 for a free consultation. You deserve to get the benefits you paid for, let us help you fight for your benefits.